Legislation Details

File #: 26-376   
Type: Report Status: Passed
File created: 8/24/2026 In control: City Council
On agenda: 11/10/2026 Final action: 11/10/2026
Effective date:    
Title: CONSIDERATION TO INITIATE IMPROVEMENTS FROM A MENU OF OPTIONS FOR THE FORSTER RANCH COMMUNITY PARK AMPHITHEATER
Attachments: 1. Att. 1 - Amphitheater Survey Results.pdf

Submitted By: City Manager

Prepared By: Alexia Gruszczynski, Executive Analyst

 

Subject:

title

CONSIDERATION TO INITIATE IMPROVEMENTS FROM A MENU OF OPTIONS FOR THE FORSTER RANCH COMMUNITY PARK AMPHITHEATER

body

 

Summary:

As requested by the City Council, staff have prepared a menu of options for improvements and uses associated with the Forster Ranch Community Park Outdoor Amphitheater. The menu of options provides different scales of improvements and uses intending to revitalize the outdoor amphitheater with consideration of the proximity to the neighboring community and associated costs.

 

 

Background:

Forster Ranch Community Park offers a variety of amenities, including sports fields, a playground, picnic structure, and an outdoor amphitheater. The sports fields are primarily used by soccer organizations, where tournaments occur on weekends and practice throughout the week. The fields do not provide lighting so these operations cannot continue throughout the evening hours. The picnic structure is rented frequently for private events, and the amphitheater hosts Movies in the Park once every spring.

 

City Staff met with a group of Forster Ranch residents who shared unique perspectives on improvements and programming options. The residents expressed general concerns about noise during sports operations, resident hosted parties/events, and vehicle traffic, but mentioned little to no impact from the current programming at the amphitheater. Overall, they agreed that amplified noise should be limited and any performance should remain family friendly and work collaboratively with the local schools.

 

Since the amphitheater abuts a local elementary and middle school, City Staff met with Capistrano Unified School District’s (CUSD) Superintendent to discuss the joint use agreement at the park and gauge the interest of expanding amphitheater programming. The Superintendent was optimistic that any additional programming, after school hours, would not significantly impact school operations and was open to amending the agreement to permit overflow parking and equipment staging on the school’s blacktop.

 

Additionally, City staff sent out a notice to property owners within 300 feet of the park and the HOA to alert residents of a sound demonstration organized by the City on October 1st. The demonstration played electronic music, with significant bass, at a high volume for 45 minutes while Staff collected noise readings. Staff drove through nearby neighborhoods and walked the park as the music played at its peak of 77 decibels. The noise reading results showed that the high impact areas (i.e., directly beneath homes on Costero Risco) was around 45 decibels, which is considered ambient noise and well within the requirements of the Municipal Code. In tandem with the demonstration, Staff included a survey requesting feedback on the type and frequency of performances. 60 Forster Ranch residents responded indicating that most are interested in increasing programming to a few times per year or a few times per month for activities like Movies in the Park, live “soft” music performance/band, and school activities. Overall, the feedback encouraged additional neighborhood friendly programming.

 

Any combination of physical improvements and additional programming is intended to enhance user experiences, increase awareness and usability of the site, and offer a desirable amenity for the citizens of San Clemente. City Staff updated Arts and Culture Committee Member Michael Wechsberg, who has expressed a great deal of interest on the progress of this report.

 

Discussion:

There are two elements of enhancement for the amphitheater: physical improvements (infrastructure) and usability improvements (programming). With direction from the City Council, Staff can research additional improvements not currently addressed in this report.

 

Physical Improvement Options

Staff have identified three different levels of physical improvements that we feel provide the most opportunity for the site to succeed without large scale fiscal impacts.

 

Level 1 - Limited Improvements and Seeking Sponsorships

In its existing state, the amphitheater can be used for some limited activities. However, even with little or no improvements, the facility needs some audio/visual equipment to expand the usability of the amphitheater. Seeking sponsorships is an opportunity to engage with interested stakeholders who may be willing to donate audio/visual equipment, infrastructure or other necessary components to help with the desired improvements.

 

The City reached out to a local vendor, the Sonance Foundation, who are considering an in-kind contribution of roughly $20,000 for equipment; however, no firm commitment has been made at this time. The Sonance equipment ensures that the sound quality is high while mitigating noise dispersion away from the amphitheater. The recommended equipment for the site is as follows: 

 

•                     Two CBL528 loudspeakers as the main left/right pair, pole-mounted at the downstage edge of the pad. These have an 180-degree horizontal pattern, so a single pair covers the full fan of the lawn, and a tight 45-degree vertical pattern that keeps energy on the audience rather than the homes beyond. Roughly 107 dB at 70 feet, which is about 10 dB of headroom over a normal program level.

•                     Two 18-inch subwoofers rather than one. This is deliberate: a pair can be configured as a cardioid array, which removes something on the order of 10 to 15 dB of bass energy behind the stage. Given how close the neighborhood and the school sit, that is the most effective noise-mitigation tool available, and it only works with two boxes.

 

•                     Two CBL523 loudspeakers as front fill, covering the first rows, which sit underneath the mains' vertical pattern and would otherwise be noticeably quieter than the middle of the lawn.

 

•                     Two amplifiers with onboard DSP - 12 channels total, with spare capacity for performer monitors. Presets still load automatically, so "Movie Night" and "Speech" are a single button for staff.

 

While seeking sponsorships, the amphitheater could still be programmed by utilizing The Friends of San Clemente PA system. The donated equipment is set up and run by a contracted sound engineer and is often used in City events. It costs about $2,500-$5,000, which covers payment for sound engineering services and staff time; however, the price ranges depending on the length of the event and number of bands/members.

 

While utilizing sponsorships contributes positively to this project, there may be certain aesthetic components that are preferred and implemented by the sponsoring group. Communication between the sponsoring group and City staff will be crucial to ensure execution of this project is considerate of the City’s needs and mindful of the surrounding communities.

 

Level 2 - Improve Electricity on Site and Provide ADA Seating

To produce high-quality experiences for all participants and attendees of amphitheater events, electricity upgrades and ADA seating should be implemented. The park currently operates on an existing 800-amp service in the parking lot, which is relatively close to the amphitheater. The power equipment includes a spare 60-amp breaker which could be added to the existing load of the 800-amp service. To extend adequate power to a removable power pedestal near the stage location requires about 300 feet of trenching. The trench will run across approximately 30 feet of asphalt and 270 feet of grass. The trench will include the necessary and appropriate conduit and the wires (see image) to the desired pedestal location. This solution is suitable for long-term use at the capacity required for the recommended amphitheater events. Additionally, it provides a dedicated power source that can be used for future expansion of the system. This allows for programming flexibility if there is demand for larger scale events in the future. To improve the electricity and power on the site will cost approximately $20,000.

 

Since this amphitheater is intended for family-friendly events, it is important to include ADA seating opportunities. On site, there are two picnic tables on top of concrete slabs that overlook the top of the amphitheater. Proper grading, an accessible path of travel and additional pads (with seating rather than picnic tables) would be needed to address ADA issues. This creates accessible seating areas next to the park benches and leaves enough room for family members to sit next to a designated ADA seat.

 

Utilizing additional concrete would blend with the existing concrete areas and require less maintenance but costs more than decomposed granite (DG). On average, DG costs roughly $5-$8 per square foot where concrete costs $8-$10 per square foot. While DG is the budget-friendly option, it requires periodic maintenance and weed management to remain well kept. Staff recommend utilizing concrete since it keeps the maintenance costs low, the durability can sustain high volumes of pedestrian foot traffic and can withstand significant weather events.

 

Level 3 - Permanent Structure

 

A permanent structure would serve as a long-term amenity for patrons, provide sound dampening for events, and signify a transition into amphitheater space. In addition, the structure can provide a location to mount audio/visual equipment, which creates versatility for the site and an opportunity to expand resources in the future. When the amphitheater is not in use, the structure would provide a large, covered area for patrons to enjoy shade on a hot summer day or take shelter during rain. A wooden structure in this area could cost between $50,000-$100,000 depending on the size, quality, and materials used.

 

Use and Programming

The Beaches, Parks, and Recreation Department executes an entertainment agreement with all prospective performances at City sanctioned events. This agreement organizes parking permits, fees, insurance, performance expectations, and permitted hours for all events. While exploring performance options, Recreation Staff looks for videos of previous performances, a social media presence, and recent set lists to understand what type of experience the community can expect. They also meet with each performer in advance to inform them that a family-friendly performance is required and any violations could result in losing their deposit. The execution of an agreement would still be required for live music programming at the amphitheater and could be customized to permit specific genres of music and types of performances.

 

Initially, the City will be the sole event organizer, and the amphitheater would not be rented to outside parties. Upon further assessment of increased programming and physical improvements, the City could consider renting out the space in the future once feedback is received from the additional programming at this site.

 

Additional Programming:

Based on conversations with community stakeholders, a community survey, and City organized demonstration, Staff feel that the following uses would be compatible with the site:

 

•                     Acoustical (or very low amplified) Music - These could be performances from local schools or professional musicians. This type of music would use very limited sound amplification (i.e. single microphone for voice without guitar amplification). Typically, acoustic artists focus on family-friendly songs with a mellow tune.

 

•                     Chamber Music - These could be performances by small groups of students or musicians that perform symphonic music. This type of music lacks vocalization and would require minimal amplification depending on the instruments used.

 

•                     School Performances - The City could partner with the local elementary, middle, and high schools to perform holiday plays or other seasonal performances. This would likely require limited amplification for microphones and/or background music.

 

•                     Live Music/Band - The City hosts a variety of bands during other community events like the Summer Beach Concert Series. The City could add the Forster Ranch Community Park Amphitheater as a location to program these events. Generally, concerts will require amplified sound, staging, and lighting.

 

Considerations Identified by Staff:

To date, the amphitheater has not been utilized to host small scale concerts or plays, live music performances or bands, or school activities. Staff believe physical improvement Levels 1 and 2 provide the most community benefit while keeping costs relatively low and the suggested additional programming options retain a family-friendly environment while expanding the amphitheaters’ usability.

 

Level 1 is an opportunity to explore expanding programming options, utilizing existing City event equipment, which is proven to work via the October 1st demonstration, prior to physical improvements. Staff can assess any impacts on the surrounding neighborhood and determine if amplification or other infrastructure is suitable for the site, while engaging stakeholders for future potential sponsorships.

 

Level 2 explores improvements that provide substantial benefits to the community attending the events. Enhancing the electrical equipment and power sources ensures these events provide adequate systems for performers and creates an opportunity for expansion in the future. Constructing ADA seating ensures this amenity is accessible to all.

 

Finally, the additional programming options introduce a new musical experience to the community while keeping sound levels tame. And, based upon the community survey, the suggested programming options would be welcomed by residents of Forster Ranch. To assess if preferred programming options have changed with the community, City staff intend to provide annual check-ins with Forster Ranch HOA.

 

Council Options:

•                     Direct staff to initiate all the improvements to the amphitheater at Forster Ranch Community Park.

 

•                     Direct staff to initiate a selection of improvements to the amphitheater at Forster Ranch Community Park.

 

•                     Direct staff to initiate review of additional improvement options.

 

•                     Decline to proceed with any of the improvement options.

 

Environmental Review/Analysis:

Discussion of this project is not a project as defined by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The appropriate level of environmental review will occur at the appropriate time in compliance with CEQA.

 

Fiscal Impact:

None at the discussion stage. There is a significant variance in cost depending on the direction provided by the City Council.

 

Potential Action(s):

recommendation

There is no action required by the City Council at this time. Additional discussion and formal direction from the City Council will advance this item to the next steps.

 

end

Attachment:

1.                     Amphitheater Survey Results

 

Notification:

Notification within 300 feet of Forster Ranch Community Park

Interested Parties