Submitted By: Public Works
Prepared By: Dustin Burnside, Utilities Manager
Subject:
PUBLIC HEARING FOR THE CONSIDERATION OF ORDINANCE NO. 1815, AMENDING CHAPTER 13.04 OF THE CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE MUNICIPAL CODE, AND RESOLUTION NO. 26-180, ADJUSTING WATER DEPARTMENT FEE SCHEDULE FOR MISCELLANEOUS WATER FEES, AS PREVIOUSLY APPROVED BY RESOLUTION NOS. 10-048 AND 12-060
Summary:
As part of the Water Rate Study, Water Resources Economics (WRE) was tasked with analyzing the miscellaneous fees schedule to fully recover the City’s costs associated with providing other miscellaneous services to the water customers in the City of San Clemente. WRE worked with City staff to evaluate labor and material costs along with time needed to complete various tasks beyond delivery of water to customers. The last adjustment to Miscellaneous Fees were completed in 2010 and there have been significant increases in labor and equipment costs, as well as materials, such as, asphalt, brass and copper.
If the City Council approves City staff’s recommendation, it includes both an update in the fee amounts set by resolution, and an ordinance to update the procedures for Council setting future fee amounts by resolution. In addition, City staff has identified the need to establish penalties for violations of backflow protection regulations due to additional staff time needed to obtain required regulatory agency required annual backflow device certification to protect public health and safety for all water users.
Discussion:
At the May 06, 2025, City Council Meeting, WRE was awarded the contract for a Cost-Of-Service Study for the City’s Water Utility. While the water rates were adopted in March of 2026, the second part of the study was completed after water rates were approved. As part of the Miscellaneous Fee Study, Water Resources Economics was tasked with reviewing water related service fees to recover costs associated with the service. WRE evaluated City fully burdened labor rates, equipment costs and material costs. Time to complete tasks was evaluated through the use of Lucity, the City’s Computer Maintenance Management System and compared to the time it takes other cities/agencies to complete similar tasks. The proposed fee amounts are no more than necessary to cover the City’s estimated reasonable costs of providing the services, and the costs are proportionately allocated to each fee payor based on their respective benefits from or burdens on the services, and each updated fee falls within one or more of the following five exceptions to the definition of “tax” as set forth in Proposition 26:
a. The amount of the fee does not exceed the City’s costs of providing a specific benefit to the payor; or
b. The amount of the fee does not exceed the City’s costs of providing a service or product to the payor; or
c. The amount of the fee does not exceed the City’s costs of regulation (including licensing, permitting, investigation, inspecting, auditing, or enforcement); or
d. The amount of the fee does not exceed the value of City land authorized by the City for use by the payor; or
e. The amount of the fee is a fine or penalty for a violation of law; and
The majority of proposed fee changes have nominal increases or fee reductions, with the exception of significant increases associated with meter installations as shown in the Miscellaneous Fees Schedule below. The proposed new penalty fee for backflow certification is associated with customers not meeting the annual state mandated requirement to provide the City with backflow certification by a certified tester. This regulatory requirement is in place to protect the public water system (health and safety) for discharge of water back into the system from commercial, industrial and irrigation services, where water quality could be compromised.
Miscellaneous Fees Schedule
|
Fee Description |
Current Fee |
Proposed Fee |
|
Establishment Fee |
$40 |
$50 |
|
Insufficient Funds Check |
|
|
|
• Paper Check |
$20 |
$25 |
|
• E-check |
$20 |
$35 |
|
Water Disconnection/Reconnection Fee |
|
|
|
• First Occurrence |
$55 |
$65 |
|
• Second Occurrence |
$80 |
$90 |
|
• Third Occurrence |
$110 + deposit |
$120 + deposit equal to 3x average bill |
|
Curb Stop Repair - 1" |
$850 |
$415.00 |
|
Curb Stop Repair - 1.5" |
$850 |
$710.00 |
|
Curb Stop Repair - 2" |
$850 |
$835.00 |
|
Hydrant Meter Rentals |
$125 + $835 deposit and $3/day |
$150 + $835 deposit and $3/day |
|
Hydrant Meter Water Sales |
Commercial water rate |
Commercial water rate |
|
Hydrant Meter Relocation Fee |
$0 |
$125 |
|
Meter Installation Fee - 1" |
$415 |
$795 |
|
Meter Installation Fee - 1.5" |
$1525 |
$1,995 |
|
Meter Installation Fee - 2" |
$1850 |
$2,075 |
|
Meter Service Installation Fee - 1" |
$4,300 |
$12,175 |
|
Meter Service Installation Fee - 1.5" |
$5,650 |
$14,220 |
|
Meter Service Installation Fee - 2" |
$6,400 |
$15,525 |
|
Meter Service Relocation - 1" |
$7,000 |
$14,570 |
|
Meter Service Relocation - 1.5" |
$8,300 |
$15,075 |
|
Meter Service Relocation - 2" |
$9,000 |
$16,075 |
|
Meter Replacement |
$0 |
$125 |
|
Meter Service Upgrade - 1" |
$3,800 |
$12,450 |
|
Meter Service Upgrade - 1.5" |
$5,100 |
$14,470 |
|
Meter Service Upgrade - 2" |
$5,800 |
$15,975 |
|
Service Deletion Estimate |
$0 |
$520 |
|
Service Deletion |
T&M |
T&M |
|
Backflow Testing Administrative Fee |
$35 per device |
$50 per device |
|
Fire Flow Test |
$295 |
$140 |
|
Water Meter Test |
$175 |
$375 includes test fee, certification and shipping |
Penalty Fees
|
Fee Description |
Current Fee |
Proposed Fee |
|
Water Final Written Notice Fee |
$0 |
$25 |
|
Water Posting Fee |
$25 |
$25 |
|
Tampering Fee |
$200 |
$200 |
|
Meter Removal Fees |
$175 |
$175 |
|
Backflow Penalty Fees |
|
|
|
• First Occurrence |
$0 |
$25 |
|
• Second Occurrence |
$0 |
$50 |
|
• Third Occurrence |
$0 |
$100 + disconnect fee |
Considerations Identified by Staff:
Water Division staff currently performs several miscellaneous tasks at a loss due to the increased cost of labor and materials since previously studied. By directly charging a fee to customers that directly benefit from these services, additional Water Fund revenue is available to perform maintenance and repair of the water system as a whole.
While some fees studied are reduced, the majority of the large construction tasks on the Miscellaneous Fees schedule only recover one-half to one-third of the cost it takes to do perform the work. New Penalty Fees are being proposed to assist in customer compliance with maintaining proper cross-connection control safeguards through the use of backflow devices.
Council Options:
• Adopt Ordinance No. 1815 and Resolution No. 26-180, which will approve the recommended miscellaneous fee adjustments for each service performed by the Water Division.
• Amend and adopt the ordinance and resolution.
• Deny the proposed miscellaneous fee adjustments and maintain the current fees.
Environmental Review/Analysis:
The proposed action to adjust miscellaneous fees does not constitute a “project” under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15378(b), as it involves only the modification of fee schedules and will not result in a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment. The adjustment of user fees constitutes a fiscal and administrative activity that does not have the potential to cause a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment.
Fiscal Impact:
Approval of the proposed fee adjustments will improve cost recovery for the work Utilities staff does to benefit customers in need of miscellaneous services other than supplying water. The last Water Department miscellaneous fees adjustment was in 2010.
The largest fiscal impact varies depending on whether or not development projects use City staff to install meters. As the City is nearing build out, the request for meter installations should reduce in future years.
Recommended Actions:
Staff Recommendation
Staff recommends that the City Council:
1. Conduct the Public Hearing pursuant to California Government Code Section 66018(a); and,
2. Introduce Ordinance No. 1815, entitled AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCILOF THE CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE, CALIFORNIA AMENDING CHAPTER 13.04 (WATER SERVICE SYSTEM) OF THE SAN CLEMENTE MUNICIPAL CODE TO UPDATE PROCEDURE FOR SETTING FEE AMOUNTS BY RESOLUTION; and
3. Adopt Resolution No. 26-180, entitled A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SAN CLEMENTE, CALIFORNIA, UPDATING FEE SCHEDULE FOR MISCELLANEOUS WATER FEES.
Attachments:
1. Resolution No. 26-180
2. Ordinance No. 1815
3. Exhibit A Fee Schedule
4. Ordinance Ex A 13.04.250 Redline
5. Ordinance Ex B 13.04.270 Redline
6. San Clemente Misc. Fees Report
7. San Clemente Misc. Fees Model
8. Public Notice
9. Resolution No. 10-048
10. Resolution No. 12-060
Notification:
Public Notice - Orange County Register and San Clemente Times