Submitted By: Finance and Administrative Services
Prepared By: Brian Brower, Assistant City Manager
Cara Morin, Human Resources Manager
Subject:
title
CONSIDERATION OF A RESOLUTION APPROVING REVISIONS TO THE PART-TIME AND BENEFITED SALARY SCHEDULES, NEW AND UPDATED CLASSIFICATIONS, RECLASSIFICATION OF LEGISLATIVE ADMINISTRATOR TO CITY CLERK, A DIRECTOR CLASSIFICATION TITLE CHANGE, AND RELATED SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATIONS
body
Summary:
The City of San Clemente periodically reviews its classification and compensation structures to ensure they remain consistent with current operational responsibilities, applicable wage requirements, and regional labor market conditions. As part of these ongoing efforts, Human Resources conducted targeted classification and compensation reviews for several part-time positions, including Recreation Aquatics and Marine Safety classifications, and evaluated additional classification changes necessary to reflect evolving departmental responsibilities.
The proposed revisions address several distinct considerations, including changes to California’s minimum wage, salary compaction within the part-time salary schedule, recruitment and retention challenges, market competitiveness, and the alignment of classification titles and specifications with current duties and function. While each proposed adjustment addresses a specific operational need, collectively, these changes support the City’s continued efforts to maintain an appropriate and competitive classification and compensation structure.
The proposed Resolution would approve a revised hourly part-time salary schedule effective January 18, 2027; establish a part-time Golf Course Groundskeeper classification; update aquatic and marine safety classifications; make targeted Recreation Leader salary grade changes; revise the Director of Beaches, Parks, and Recreation title to Director of Community and Maintenance Services; and reclassify the Legislative Administrator to City Clerk at benefited Grade 75. The Resolution would also discontinue the separate monthly City Clerk stipend authorized by Resolution No. 99-57 upon implementation of the revised salary assignment.
Background:
On June 16, 2026, the City Council approved broader staffing and compensation adjustments through Resolution No. 26-114, including the Fiscal Year 2026-27 three percent (3%) part-time cost-of-living adjustment and a salary grade adjustment for the Director of Beaches, Parks, and Recreation. The actions presented in this report are additional targeted classification and compensation revisions.
California’s statewide minimum wage will increase to $17.40 per hour on January 1, 2027. The existing part-time salary schedule contains several lower pay grades that no longer provide a usable range at or above the new minimum. In reviewing the resulting grade structure, staff also identified compression among certain Recreation Leader and aquatic classifications that warranted further evaluation.
In addition to the wage schedule review, Human Resources evaluated current recruitment conditions and comparable agency compensation for pool and ocean lifeguards. The study considered minimum qualifications, certification requirements, assigned responsibilities, and differences among comparator classifications in order to distinguish appropriate market relationships from positions with broader or more specialized duties. Separate classification reviews were undertaken to address the City Clerk’s established statutory functions, the Director of Community and Maintenance Services’ expanded departmental oversight, and the scope of a proposed part-time golf course maintenance position.
Discussion:
I. Part-Time Salary Schedule and Recreation Leader Classifications
In conformance with minimum wage, Staff recommends removing Grades 20 through 24 from the hourly part-time salary schedule and establishing Grade 25 as the lowest listed grade. Proposed Grade 25 begins at $17.46 per hour, slightly above the January 1, 2027 statewide minimum wage. This adjustment removes lower ranges that are no longer appropriate for compensation.
To maintain appropriate internal salary relationships after removal of the lower grades, staff also recommends moving Golf Course Marshals and Interns to Grade 25 and adjusting Recreation Leader I, II, and III to Grades 25, 29, and 32 respectively. The Recreation Leader changes address salary compaction within the series; no revisions to these classifications’ duties or specifications are recommended at this time.
II. Pool Lifeguard, Water Safety Instructor, and Head Lifeguard
The City reviewed pool aquatic classifications against comparable municipal agencies to determine whether salary ranges support recruitment and retention of qualified personnel. Unlike ocean lifeguard classifications, the City’s competition for pool employees is not limited to other public agencies. Local fitness facilities, water parks, and private swim instruction providers recruit from the same regional pool of individuals with the certifications and experience necessary to support City aquatic programs.
During the 2026 summer season, the City’s Aquatics Division experienced significant challenges retaining newly hired employees. Despite successfully recruiting and onboarding qualified staff, some employees left within only a few weeks for other part-time employment opportunities, including restaurants and other non-aquatic businesses offering higher starting wages and more consistent hours. These departures created scheduling challenges and increased the risk of reduced pool operating hours or temporary closures if the City could not maintain the required lifeguard coverage. Unlike many other part-time City positions, adequate lifeguard staffing is essential to keeping aquatic facilities open and available to the public. Establishing more competitive starting wages, coupled with greater scheduling consistency where operationally feasible, will better position the City to attract and retain qualified personnel during both the off-season and peak summer months.
The market review identified average comparable hourly ranges of $19.59 to $23.07 for Pool Lifeguard, $20.98 to $24.26 for Water Safety Instructor, and $22.32 to $26.94 for Head Lifeguard. Staff recommends Grade 30 ($19.72 to $23.98) for Pool Lifeguard, Grade 33 ($21.22 to $25.79) for Water Safety Instructor, and Grade 37 ($23.39 to $28.43) for Head Lifeguard. These placements are intentionally above the municipal comparison averages to account for the broader local labor market and support reliable staffing of City aquatic services. Updated specifications reflecting current duties and qualification requirements are also included.
III. Ocean Lifeguard Classifications
The Marine Safety classification review compared San Clemente’s part-time ocean lifeguard series with positions at other coastal municipalities and California State Parks, as applicable. Comparator classifications were evaluated for assigned duties, minimum qualifications, certification requirements and the distinction between entry-level, experienced, and supervisory responsibilities. The analysis generally identified below market compensation within the City’s existing series.
Staff recommends establishing Ocean Lifeguard Trainee at Grade 27 ($18.32 to $22.28), Ocean Lifeguard I at Grade 38 ($23.98 to $29.14), Ocean Lifeguard II at Grade 42 ($26.43 to $32.13), and Ocean Lifeguard Supervisor at Grade 48 ($30.60 to $37.19). The revised specifications differentiate trainee, entry, experienced, and part-time supervisory responsibilities, while updating complexity of duties and essential functions consistent with the role of the Ocean Lifeguards today, as well as, applicable physical testing, training, emergency medical certifications, and operational requirements.
The Ocean Lifeguard II and Ocean Lifeguard Supervisor specifications also identify an Open Water Diver or SCUBA qualification as highly desirable for positions with a documented operational need for specialized underwater duties. Because these functions are not required of every employee in either classification, staff recommends allowing a discretionary one-step salary advancement, within the approved range, only when an employee holds an accepted qualification, is specifically designated to use it, and satisfies applicable City training and safety requirements. Certification alone would not establish automatic eligibility or authorize underwater operations. The administrative conditions of this provision remain subject to final review.
IV. Part-Time Golf Course Groundskeeper
Staff recommends establishing a Golf Course Groundskeeper (Part-Time) classification at Grade 32 ($20.71 to $25.17 per hour) to support routine course and landscape maintenance. The proposed specification emphasizes bunker care, landscaping, watering, grounds cleanup, basic repairs, and other semi-skilled work performed under direction. The position would not carry the same independent responsibility for advanced irrigation troubleshooting, specialized chemical treatment, heavy equipment operations, or complex maintenance projects assigned to full-time golf course maintenance classifications. Defining the duties separately recognizes the difference in scope and responsibility rather than relying solely on the employee’s part-time status to distinguish compensation discrepancies.
V. Director of Community and Maintenance Services
During discussions surrounding the July 2026 staffing changes, the City Council and staff considered updating the title of Director of Beaches, Parks, and Recreation to better reflect the position’s expanded responsibilities, including oversight of the Maintenance Division. Staff recommends the title Director of Community and Maintenance Services, together with related specification revisions, reflecting responsibility for recreation and aquatics programming, parks, beach maintenance, the golf course, and municipal maintenance functions. The position’s salary adjustment was previously approved; no additional compensation, staffing, or reporting relationship change is proposed at this time.
VI. City Clerk Reclassification and Stipend
Following the City’s historical transition from an elected to an appointed City Clerk, the position was subsequently designated Legislative Administrator, while the Legislative Administrator continued performance the City’s core City Clerk functions. San Clemente Municipal Code 2.10.010 provides for appointment of the City Clerk by the City Manager. Human Resources reviewed the historical classification, current duties, and comparable (appointed) municipal City Clerk positions and recommends restoring the City Clerk title, updating the specification to reflect the statutory, legislative, records, and elections responsibilities of the position, and assigning the position to mid-management Grade 75 instead of 72.
The compensation review of seven municipalities identified an average City Clerk salary range midpoint of approximately $80.38 per hour. The proposed Grade 75 midpoint is approximately $80.44 per hour and is consistent with market findings. Staff also obtained written clarification from CalPERS concerning membership eligibility for an appointed City Clerk position without a fixed term. Implementation will remain subject to applicable CalPERS compensation reporting and publicly available pay schedule requirements.
Resolution No. 99-57 established separate additional compensation of $500 per month for the City Clerk (and City Treasurer). As part of the proposed reclassification for salary review, staff recommends discontinuing this separate stipend for the City Clerk concurrently with the new Grade 75 salary assignment. The Resolution would amend only the applicable stipend authorization, preserve compensation earned before the implementation date, and leave unrelated portions of Resolution 99-57 in effect.
Considerations Identified by Staff:
Maintaining salary ranges that reflect current wage requirements and regional labor conditions is important to the City’s ability to recruit and retain qualified part-time staff, particularly for seasonal aquatic and marine safety services. The proposed adjustments address identified market deficiencies while accounting for internal salary relationships and the operational qualifications necessary to provide these services.
The additional classification revisions clarify the work and level of responsibility associated with each position. The City Clerk change aligns the classification with duties already assigned to the position, the Director title reflects an expanded area of oversight, and the new Groundskeeper specification establishes a distinct scope of part-time work. These changes do not, by themselves, increase authorized staffing levels.
Council Options:
• Adopt Resolution No. 26-195 approving the classification changes and revised salary schedule effective January 18, 2027.
• Modify and adopt Resolution No. 26-195.
• Continue the item with direction given to staff.
• Deny the Resolution and take no action.
Environmental Review/Analysis:
The proposed action is not a project subject to review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
Fiscal Impact:
Implementation of the proposed salary schedule adjustments will result in increased salary costs for some of the affected classifications. For the remainder of the current Fiscal Year, costs are estimated at approximately $45,260. Cost savings from position vacancies during the first half of the year will offset this increase, therefor these modifications will not require supplemental Budget appropriations in Fiscal Year 2026-27.
The implementation cost in FY 2027-28 is estimated at $94,690. A supplemental appropriation from General Fund Balance is being requested in the amounts of $34,100 to Account No. 001-625-41030, $53,630 to Account No. 001-641-41030, and $6,960 to Account No. 001-131-41010. Costs in future years will be addressed through the regular biennial budget process.
Potential Action(s):
recommendation
If the City Council concurs with the information provided within this staff report, moving this item without modifications would result in adoption of Resolution No. 26-195, which would:
1. Approve and adopt revisions to the Benefited and Part-time Salary Schedules.
2. Approve updated position classification specifications.
3. Approve title change of the Director of Beaches, Parks, and Recreation to Director of Community and Maintenance Services.
4. Approve reclassification of the Legislative Administrator to City Clerk.
end
Attachment:
1. Resolution No. 26-195
2. Exhibit A to Resolution No. 26-195 - Revised Salary Schedule for Benefited Positions effective January 18, 2027
3. Exhibit B to Resolution No. 26-195 - Revised Salary Schedule for Part-Time Positions effective January 18, 2027
4. Exhibit C to Resolution No. 99-57 City Clerk Stipend Provision
5. Job Descriptions:
a. Ocean Lifeguard Trainee, Ocean Lifeguard I/II (P/T)
b. Ocean Lifeguard Supervisor (P/T)
c. Pool Lifeguard (P/T)
d. Water Safety Instructor (P/T)
e. Head Lifeguard (P/T)
f. Golf Groundskeeper (P/T)
g. City Clerk
h. Director of Community and Maintenance Services
6. Market & Classification Compensation Study (Part-Time Lifeguards (Aquatics and Marine Safety)
Notification:
None.