Submitted By: Planning Division
Prepared By: Jessica Gatny, Associate Planner
Subject:
title
PUBLIC HEARING CONCERNING AN OVERVIEW OF THE MILLS ACT PROGRAM AND CONSIDERATION OF FOUR RESOLUTIONS AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE FOUR HISTORIC PROPERTY PRESERVATION AGREEMENTS, EACH FOR A QUALIFIED HISTORIC PROPERTY, AND FINDING THE ACTION CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT FROM THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT
body
Summary:
The Mills Act program, implemented through the approval of property-specific Historic Property Preservation Agreements (HPPAs), provides a property tax reduction incentive to owners of historic properties with the intent that cost savings are invested into the historic property to restore, improve, and preserve their buildings and grounds, per a 10-year term work list. For the City Council’s consideration are HPPAs for the following four historic properties:
1. 103 Avenida Del Mar (HPPA 26-315)
2. 124 Avenida San Dimas (HPPA 26-314)
3. 212 West Avenida Valencia (HPPA 26-313)
4. 310 Encino Lane (HPPA 26-091)
Background:
Enacted in 1972, the Mills Act legislation grants participating local governments the authority to enter into contracts with owners of qualified historic properties who actively participate in the restoration and maintenance of their historic properties while receiving property tax relief. In San Clemente, a “qualified” property is any property on the City’s designated list of historic structures. Mills Act Agreements are known in the City of San Clemente as HPPAs. See Attachment 6 for additional background on the Mills Act.
Participants in the Mills Act program may realize substantial property tax savings of up to 70% in the initial year of the agreement. The County Assessor applies a special restricted rate; however, this rate is not subject to Prop 13, so the assessment can increase by more than 2% annually. If property owners maintain ownership long enough, the Mills Act restricted rate may exceed the Prop 13 rate, at which time the County Assessor would apply the lower rate. The contract carries a minimum ten-year commitment and includes an automatic annual renewal. Either party may choose to end the contract; however, there is a significant financial penalty to the property owner if the City cancels the contract due to noncompliance with the terms.
The City currently has 99 active HPPAs. City staff ensure the terms and conditions of these agreements are met by conducting 5-year inspections, paid for by the historic property owners. City staff will be inspecting 30-35 properties to ensure compliance with the agreements in November 2026. An example of a periodic inspection report is provided in Attachment 7. Through this process, staff, with the support of the City’s on-call historic preservation consultant, can identify maintenance tasks beyond those originally identified in the preliminary 10-year work plan.
Discussion:
On August 21, 2026, staff and the City’s historic preservation consultant, GPA Consulting (GPA), conducted site visits at the four subject properties to evaluate the condition of the historic resource and determine which improvements should be pursued for the rehabilitation and maintenance of the property. The prioritized work items for the properties are provided in the attached resolutions (Attachments 1-4).
The list of prioritized work was reviewed by the Design Review Subcommittee (DRSC), which serves as the Cultural Heritage Subcommittee (CHSC), on October 14, 2026. The CHSC reviewed the HPPAs requested and supported the recommended lists of prioritized work. See Attachment 5 for the CHSC meeting minutes. The property owners would need to apply for and receive applicable permits at the time work is proposed consistent with HPPA requirements and Secretary of the Interior Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (Exhibit B of each Resolution, Attachments 1-4).
If approved by Council, the HPPAs will be executed after the owners submit the required $380 filing fee. The executed HPPAs will then be recorded with the County and forwarded to the Tax Assessor. The exact amount of the special assessment will only be known after the County Tax Assessor completes a valuation for the property in 2027 based on the executed agreements. To confirm compliance with the conditions of the agreements, every five years from the commencement of the contract’s term, the property owner will be responsible to arrange a site inspection with the Planning Division and pay for the costs of such inspection.
Considerations Identified by Staff:
The Mills Act program establishes a contractual relationship between the City and participating property owners. In exchange for potential property tax savings, owners commit to completing specified improvements during the initial 10-year contract term and maintaining their historic properties in accordance with the agreement. This arrangement provides a financial incentive for private investment in historic preservation while supporting the City's broader goal of protecting its historic resources for future generations.
To qualify for the program, a property must contain a designated historic resource. Property owners are responsible for completing the improvements specified in their agreements, obtaining applicable permits, complying with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties, and maintaining their properties. The City monitors compliance through periodic five-year inspections.
Staff screens and educates prospective applicants before application submittal to ensure they understand the program’s requirements and responsibilities. Throughout the process, staff and the CHSC work collaboratively with property owners to establish and prioritize work plans that are practical, achievable, and financially manageable. Where feasible, the timing and sequencing of improvements are coordinated with anticipated annual property tax savings to help owners plan for rehabilitation and maintenance costs.
In developing the work plans, staff prioritizes improvements based on the condition of the historic resource and the relative importance of each item to the property’s preservation. Structural repairs and other items that may threaten a building’s structural integrity are given priority, followed by aesthetic improvements. Aesthetic improvements are then prioritized according to the affected building elevations or site areas in the following order: (1) primary elevations and yards, typically the front of the property; (2) secondary elevations and yards, typically the sides; and (3) tertiary elevations and yards, typically the rear. This approach establishes a consistent framework for prioritizing improvements while allowing property owners to plan for and complete the required work over the initial 10-year contract term.
Council Options:
• Adopt the attached Resolutions, authorizing the City Manager to execute al subject Historic Property Preservation Agreements.
• Modify and adopt the attached Resolutions.
• Continue the item and direct staff to provide additional information.
• Deny the attached Resolutions, denying the approval of the Historic Property Preservation Agreements.
Environmental Review/Analysis:
Historic preservation agreements are categorically exempt under Class 31, Section 15378 of the California Environmental Quality Act Guidelines (14 CCR § 15331 - Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation) because they consist of preservation of a historical resource and its maintenance, repair, rehabilitation or restoration in a manner consistent with the Secretary of the Interior Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, Restoring, and Reconstructing Historic Buildings.
Fiscal Impact:
Execution of the four HPPAs will result in a reduction of property tax revenues to the City of approximately $69,356 in total per year.
Potential Action(s):
recommendationrecommendation
If the City Council concurs with the contents of this report, the City Council may adopt Resolution No. 26-175, Resolution No. 26-176, Resolution No. 26-177, and Resolution No. 26-178 which will:
1. Find the four Historic Property Preservation Agreements categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act under Class 31, Section 15378 of the CEQA Guidelines (14 CCR §15331 - Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation); and
2. Authorize the City Manager to execute the associated Historic Property Preservation Agreements.
end
Attachments:
1. Resolution No. 26-175
a. Exhibit 1: 103 Avenida Del Mar Mills Act Contract
2. Resolution No. 26-176
a. Exhibit 1: 124 Avenida San Dimas Mills Act Contract
3. Resolution No. 26-177
a. Exhibit 1: 212 West Avenida Valencia Mills Act Contract
4. Resolution No. 26-178
a. Exhibit 1: 310 Encino Lane Mills Act Contract
5. Minutes from the CHSC Meeting of October 14, 2026
6. Mills Act Background Information
7. Example Periodic Inspection Report
Notification:
Public notices were distributed and posted per City and State requirements. The City has not received any public comments on this item to-date.