Legislation Details

File #: 26-404   
Type: Resolution Status: Passed
File created: 9/18/2026 In control: City Council
On agenda: 11/10/2026 Final action: 11/10/2026
Effective date:    
Title: CONSIDERATION OF A RESOLUTION AWARDING A CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT TO PANTHEON DIVERSIFIED, INC. FOR LIFEGUARD TOWERS REPLACEMENT (2026), CIP PROJECT NO. 17144, AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE THE CONTRACT IN THE AMOUNT OF $82,998, AND FINDING THE PROJECT CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT FROM THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT
Attachments: 1. Att. 1 - Resolution No. 26-185.pdf, 2. Att. 2 - Construction Contract.pdf, 3. Att. 3 - Location Plan (Admin Report).pdf, 4. Att. 4 - Bid Protest letter.pdf, 5. Att. 5 - Bid Protest Response Letter.pdf, 6. Att. 6 - Pantheon Diversified Inc. bid.pdf, 7. Att. 7 - Capo A General Contracting bid.pdf, 8. Att. 8 - Pantheon Diversified Inc. Affidavid for digital signature.pdf

Submitted By: Public Works

Prepared By: Belgin Cuhadaroglu, Senior Civil Engineer

 

Subject:

title

CONSIDERATION OF A RESOLUTION AWARDING A CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT TO PANTHEON DIVERSIFIED, INC. FOR LIFEGUARD TOWERS REPLACEMENT (2026), CIP PROJECT NO. 17144, AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE THE CONTRACT IN THE AMOUNT OF $82,998, AND FINDING THE PROJECT CATEGORICALLY EXEMPT FROM THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT

body

 

Summary:

The proposed Resolution (Attachment 1) would award a construction contract to Pantheon Diversified, Inc., in an amount not to exceed $82,998 (Attachment 2), to replace two Lifeguard Towers that are nearing the end of their useful life.

 

Background:

San Clemente beaches accommodate approximately 2.6 million visitors each year. Marine Safety has responsibility for providing beach safety and water-related lifeguard services. To maintain and improve emergency response, staff use lifeguard towers for better visibility and to store safety equipment. Currently, lifeguards utilize 11 towers: ten wooden and one fiberglass. This is the third phase of tower replacements: six out of 11 towers 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7) were replaced in 2024 and 2025.

 

 

The new replacement towers are being constructed from wood to improve safety and address challenges in obtaining replacement parts for fiberglass towers. This will follow the construction of the previous six towers built in 2024 and 2025. This project proposes to replace towers eleven (11) and fourteen (14), which are nearing the end of their useful life. Photos of the recently constructed towers in 2025 are shown below.

 

    

 

 

Discussion:

On August 27, 2026, City staff conducted a formal bid for replacing the two lifeguard towers, notified local contractors, and advertised the project for competitive bidding on the PlanetBids website and in the SC Times. The City received 11 bids, ranging from $82,998 to $460,919.50. Bids are tabulated in Table 1, Bid Summary, below:

 

Table 1. Bid Summary

Vendor Name

Location

Base Bid ($)

Pantheon Diversified, Inc

San Clemente

82,998

Capo A General Contracting

San Juan Capistrano

98,700

Full Swing Construction, Inc.

Garden Grove

100,000

U.S. Builders & Consultants Inc.

Irvine

118,900

EMH Construction LLC

Carlsbad

119,000

GQ Builders, Inc.

Rancho Santa Fe

124,500

CUBIC ENGINEERING Inc

Costa Mesa

128,400

OrangeBlue General Contractors

Laguna Hills

143,000

CABIFORNIA INC

Mission Viejo

302,000

AQUAPHOENIX BUILDERS

Buena Park

334,872

CALTEC Corp.

Irvine

460,919

 

The apparent low bidder for the base bid amount is from Pantheon Diversified, Inc. of San Clemente, California, at $82,998. Following the bid opening, staff received two bid protest letters from Full Swing Construction, Inc. (Attachment 4) alleging irregularities in the Pantheon Diversified, Inc. (apparent low bidder) bid documents (Bid Protest No. 1), and Capo A General Contracting (second lowest bidder) bid documents (Bid Protest No. 2).

 

A city generally has discretion to determine bid responsiveness and may either demand strict compliance with the bid specifications or waive a defect that is inconsequential or an immaterial deviation. See Taylor Bus Serv., Inc. v. San Diego Bd. of Educ. (1987) 195 Cal.App.3d 1331, 1343. A bid defect cannot be considered inconsequential or immaterial if it gives the bidder an unfair competitive advantage or benefit over other bidders.

 

Bid Protest No. 1

Full Swing Construction, Inc. challenged the responsiveness of Pantheon Diversified, Inc.’s bid based on alleged irregularities, including the absence of a separate cost for delivery or drop-off of the towers, a zero-dollar cost for the temporary security fencing bid item, the inclusion of fencing placement and installation costs within the mobilization item rather than as a separate bid item, and the use of digital signatures on the bid documents.

 

Staff and the City Attorney's office, reviewed the alleged irregularities raised by Full Swing Construction, Inc., the bid documents, Pantheon Diversified, Inc.’s responses to the protest and supporting documentation, and the applicable bid requirements. Based on this review, Staff finds that the identified irregularities are inconsequential and immaterial bid defects and do not render Pantheon Diversified, Inc.’s bid nonresponsive.

 

The bid documents permit construction of the towers at the lifeguard headquarters site; therefore, a separate delivery or drop-off cost was not required. Pantheon Diversified, Inc. owns temporary security fencing and included the placement and installation costs within mobilization costs, which is standard practice on construction projects. Pantheon Diversified, Inc. also provided an affidavit supporting the validity of the digital signatures included in its bid. These matters do not change Pantheon Diversified, Inc.’s bid price or scope of work, affect its contractual obligations or ability to perform the required work, or provide a competitive advantage.

 

Bid Protest No. 2

Full Swing Construction, Inc. also challenged the responsiveness of Capo A General Contracting’s (second lowest bid) bid based on the omission of Section 00440 - List of Subcontractors and Section 00460 - Public Works Contractor Registration Certification. Capo A General Contractors stated that it intended to self-perform the work and therefore had no subcontractors to identify, and acknowledged that it inadvertently omitted the Public Works Contractor Registration Certification from its bid. Staff reviewed the issues raised by Full Swing, Capo A General Contractors' response, the bid documents, and the applicable requirements. Staff confirmed that Capo A General Contractors was registered with the California Department of Industrial Relations at the time of bid submission and that the omissions did not change Capo A General Contractors’ bid price, scope of work, or contractual obligations. Based on this review, Staff finds that the identified omissions are inconsequential and immaterial bid defects and do not render Capo A General Contractors’ bid nonresponsive.

 

Based on the foregoing review and the responses to the protests concerning Pantheon Diversified, Inc. and Capo A General Contracting, Staff finds that Pantheon Diversified, Inc.’s bid is responsive and that the alleged irregularities identified in the protest are inconsequential and immaterial bid defects that do not affect the bid’s price, scope of work, contractual obligations, or the bidder’s ability to perform the required work; therefore, Staff recommends that the City Council waive any minor irregularities and award the contract to Pantheon Diversified, Inc. as the lowest responsive and responsible bidder.

 

Based on Pantheon Diversified, Inc.'s low bid and other construction costs, Table 2 summarizes the total estimated construction cost.

 

Table 2. Cost Summary

Administrative and Project Management

$  10,000

Engineering Construction Support and Inspection

$    5,000

Construction

$  82,998

Estimated Total Construction Cost

$  97,998

 

As required by state law and City policy, the Contractor will be required to provide performance and payment bonds simultaneously with execution of the construction contract (Attachment 2). Project plans and specifications are on file in the City Clerk’s office.

 

Considerations Identified by Staff:

Lifeguard towers 11 and 14 are nearing the end of their useful life and require replacement to ensure the City continues to provide safe, reliable, and functional facilities for lifeguard operations. Replacing the towers will address the aging condition of the existing structures, reduce the need for ongoing repairs and maintenance, and provide facilities that meet current safety, accessibility, and operational needs.

If the City defers replacement, it would need to continue maintaining and monitoring the existing towers and addressing repairs or deficiencies as they arise. As the structures continue to age, maintenance and repair needs may increase, and unexpected repairs or temporary closures could affect lifeguard operations and the delivery of beach safety services.

Council Options:

•                     Adopt Resolution No. 26-185 (Attachment 1), awarding a contract to Pantheon Diversified, Inc. as the lowest responsible bidder submitting a responsive bid, and finding the project categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Section 15302 of the state CEQA Guidelines, Class 2, and authorizing the City Manager to execute a construction contract in an amount not to exceed $82,998.

 

•                     Modify and adopt Resolution No. 26-185 for the Lifeguard Towers Replacement (2026) Project.

 

•                     Continue the item and direct staff to provide additional information.

 

•                     Do not adopt Resolution No. 26-185 and put the project on hold.

 

Environmental Review/Analysis:

This project is categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Class 2 of the State CEQA Guidelines, Section 15302 - Replacement of Existing Facilities, since it consists of replacement of existing lifeguard towers where the new towers will be located on the same site as the towers replaced and will have substantially the same purpose and capacity.

 

Fiscal Impact:

The estimated construction cost of $97,998 is within the approved available budget of the Capital Improvement Fund, Lifeguard Towers Replacement (2026), Account No. 014-811-45300-000-17144.

 

Potential Action(s):

recommendation

If the City Council concurs with the information provided within this staff report, moving this item without modifications would result in adoption of Resolution No. 26-185, which will: recommendation

 

1.                     Find the Lifeguard Towers Replacement Project No. 17144, categorically exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Section 15302 of the state CEQA Guidelines, Class 2 (replacement of existing facilities);

 

2.                     Deny the bid protest submitted by Full Swing Construction Inc., and waive the immaterial bid irregularity in the bid submitted by Pantheon Diversified, Inc. and Capo A General Contracting;

 

3.                     Award the Lifeguard Towers Replacement (2026), CIP Project No. 17144, construction contract to Pantheon Diversified, Inc. as the lowest responsible and responsive bidder; and

 

4.                     Authorize the City Manager to execute a construction contract with Pantheon Diversified, Inc. in the amount not to exceed $82,998, in a form substantially similar to Contract No. C26-61 (Attachment 2).

 

 

end

Attachment:

1.                     Resolution No. 26-185

2.                     Construction Contract with Pantheon Diversified, Inc. (without attachments; attachments on file with the City Engineer)

3.                     Location Map

4.                     Bid Protest Letter

5.                     Bid Protest Response Letter

6.                     Pantheon Diversified Inc. bid

7.                     Capo A General Contracting bid

8.                     Pantheon Diversified Inc. Authorization Letter

 

Notification:

All Bidders.