Legislation Details

File #: 26-399   
Type: Public Hearings Status: Passed
File created: 9/9/2026 In control: City Council
On agenda: 11/10/2026 Final action: 11/10/2026
Effective date:    
Title: PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A RESOLUTION PROVIDING POLICY DIRECTION AND INITIATING PREPARATION OF POTENTIAL ZONING CODE AND SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENTS CONCERNING INCLUSIONARY HOUSING REQUIREMENTS; DIRECTING FURTHER EVALUATION OF AN UPDATED IN-LIEU FEE; AND FINDING THIS ACTION IS NOT A PROJECT UNDER THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT
Attachments: 1. Att. 1 - City Council Resolution No. 26-179, 2. Att. 2 - Draft Planning Commission Resolution September 2, 2026, 3. Att. 3 - Houseal Lavigne Summary of Updated Memorandum, 4. Att. 4 - Houseal Lavigne Technical Memorandum– Redline Copy, 5. Att. 5 - Houseal Lavigne Technical Memorandum– Clean Copy, 6. Att. 6 - Public Comment .pdf

Submitted By: Community Development

Prepared By: Araceli Mejia, Assistant Planner

                                            Zach Rehm, City Planner

Subject:

title

PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A RESOLUTION PROVIDING POLICY DIRECTION AND INITIATING PREPARATION OF POTENTIAL ZONING CODE AND SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENTS CONCERNING INCLUSIONARY HOUSING REQUIREMENTS; DIRECTING FURTHER EVALUATION OF AN UPDATED IN-LIEU FEE; AND FINDING THIS ACTION IS NOT A PROJECT UNDER THE CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT

body

 

Summary:

This report presents the results of an updated evaluation of the City’s Inclusionary Housing Program (IHP) and requests City Council direction on potential amendments. Program 6: Inclusionary Housing Program, of the certified 2021-2029 Housing Element calls for evaluation of the program’s affordability set-aside and in-lieu fee. The evaluation also identified differing set-aside percentages in the Municipal Code, Housing Element, and several Specific Plans. The Council is asked to identify a preferred policy approach and authorize staff to prepare the corresponding amendments and return with a proposed in-lieu fee for future consideration. No ordinance amendment or new fee would be adopted through the requested action.

 

Background:

Inclusionary Housing Program

 

The City’s certified 2021-2029 Housing Element identifies programs intended to expand and preserve housing opportunities at different income levels. Program 6 calls for continued implementation and evaluation of the IHP, including its affordability set-aside and in-lieu fee. Currently, the Housing Element describes a 4% set-aside requirement for qualifying developments, while the Zoning Code specifies 15%.  The subject program update is required for compliance with the Housing Element, which describes the IHP as follows:

 

“San Clemente adopted an Inclusionary Housing Program (IHP) in 1980 to expand affordable housing options in San Clemente. San Clemente’s IHP requires developers of six or more units to set aside four percent of the total number of units for households earning 50 percent or less of the median income. This affordable requirement can be provided either on-site or off-site, or through payment of an in-lieu fee or provision of land. The in-lieu fee option was intended primarily for small to midsize in-fill developments or subdivisions where insufficient land exists to provide both for-sale and rental units.”

 

 

 

 

Past Actions

 

On December 18, 2018, City Council directed staff to initiate a Zoning Amendment to update the IHP and in-lieu fee. On March 2, 2020, City Council approved the professional services agreement with Economic Planning Systems, INC. (EPS) for the project.

 

Joint Study Sessions with City Council and the Planning Commission occurred on September 2, 2020, and December 16, 2020, and informed the final EPS report. On March 3, 2021, the Planning Commission recommended approval of the recommendations in the EPS report.

 

On April 20, 2021, the City Council considered recommendations to revise the inclusionary housing set-aside requirement and establish a per-square-foot in-lieu fee. The Council considered an alternative approach during its deliberations; however, the proposed ordinance was not ultimately adopted. Accordingly, the existing Zoning Code provisions, including the 15% set-aside, remained in effect. The present review builds on that earlier work and evaluates policy options using updated information.

 

Inconsistencies

 

The certified Housing Element and certain Specific Plans reference a 4% set-aside requirement, whereas the Zoning Code specifies a 15% set-aside for qualifying residential projects. These differences create uncertainty for applicants and warrant coordinated amendments to the applicable documents. Program 6 also directs the City to evaluate the feasibility of a 15% requirement and update the in-lieu fee methodology.

 

Program 6 includes two objectives for the 2021-2029 Housing Element cycle:

 

1.                     Continue implementation of the Inclusionary Housing Program; and

 

2.                     By 2025, the City will retain a consultant to evaluate the effectiveness of the Inclusionary Housing Program in facilitating the development of all income levels, and conduct a feasibility study to evaluate increasing the inclusionary housing requirement from 4% very low to 15% (5% very low, 5% low, and 5% moderate). Updated to the Inclusionary Housing Program will reflect the new requirement with a corresponding updated in-lieu fee (paid if affordable units are not provided on-site) to reflect current land and construction costs, and other related updates.

 

In 2025, during the current Housing Element Cycle, staff identified available grant funding and entered into an agreement with the Orange County Council of Governments (with funding passed through the Southern California Association of Governments) to receive technical assistance from economic development consultant Houseal Lavigne (Consultant) to evaluate the IHP. Funds for the technical assistance was provided through the Regional Early Action Plan (REAP) 2.0 program, supported by the California Department of Housing and Community Development.

 

The City’s Zoning Ordinance (SCMC § 17.24.120) currently provides that 15% of new housing units in developments of six or more units be provided at several affordable income levels, depending on whether offered for rent or for sale:

1.                     Number and Type of Units Required. New developments subject to the Inclusionary Housing Program in the City’s Housing Element shall provide affordable residential units equal to 15 percent of the new units, according to the following requirements:

 

a.                     Rental Units. Seven and one-half percent of the new units must be very low-income units and seven and one-half percent must be low-income units.

 

b.                     For-Sale Units. Three percent of new units must be very low-income units, four percent must be low-income units, four percent must be moderate income (level 1), and four percent must be moderate income (level 2).

 

Additionally, the Forster Ranch Specific Plan, Pier Bowl Specific Plan, and West Pico Corridor Specific Plan include references to 4% inclusionary housing requirements; the Marblehead Coastal Specific Plan, Rancho San Clemente Specific Plan, and Talega Specific Plan include references to 15% inclusionary housing requirements, which should be updated for consistency with whichever percentage the City Council adopts through the recommended amendments.

                                 

The conflict between the Housing Element, the Zoning Code, and the Specific Plans may be resolved by establishing a consistent set-aside, such as the IHP’s current 4%, 10%, 15%, or another supported percentage.  Any selected approach should be reflected consistently in the Zoning Code and affected Specific Plans, with appropriate consideration of Housing Element consistency.  

 

Discussion:

The Consultant revisited the methodology used in the 2021 economic analysis and updated its assumptions to reflect more recent market conditions. In their research, they found that the methodology established in the 2021 analysis remains a sound framework, but doesn’t reflect current market conditions. In the updated memo presented to the Planning Commission <https://www.sanclemente.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Item/2372?fileID=14307>, the Consultant recommended a 10% or 15% set-aside requirement with a respective $42.38 per square foot or $63.58 per square foot in-lieu fee. The feasibility included a peer-review of surrounding cities and their implementation of the IHP. 

 

To address the primary issue of inconsistencies in City documents regarding the set-aside requirement, the Planning Commission recommended that the City Council initiate a Zoning Amendment to update the percentage from 15% to 4% for the San Clemente Municipal Code and Specific Plans. Additionally, the Commission recommended researching the feasibility of a tiered structure for set-aside requirements and in-lieu fees to prevent disproportionately affecting the production of smaller scale housing developments. The Planning Commission also requested additional San Clemente-specific information and consideration of the effects on smaller projects.

 

The Consultant has taken the Planning Commission’s feedback and updated their technical memorandum which is included as Attachment 4. The consultant has documented the two-part static pro forma methodology and affordability gap to clarify how the feasibility analysis was calculated and how the inputs originated. The memo now includes projects that the City has processed which applied the IHP.

 

The Planning Commission recommended that the feasibility for increasing the set-aside requirement be based on city-specific evidence. To address this, the consultant added empirical evidence from local projects (this information is provided beginning on Page 30 of Attachment 5 under the section, “San Clemente Development Feasibility and Project Case Studies”).

 

The updated Consultant memorandum identifies a 10% set-aside outside the Housing Overlay Zone as one potential approach, while maintaining the separate 20% low-income/40% moderate-income requirement in the Housing Overlay Zone per SCMC 17.56.090, where commercial land-use conversion and ministerial review support a higher threshold. This is the “breaking point” standard for in-fill developments, which is higher than the Zoning Code set-aside requirement of 15%. Thus, the Consultant recommendation to lower the set-aside requirement to 10% outside the Housing Overlay is identified as feasible, with a potential tiered in-lieu fee requirement as a means to reducing the cost-burden on smaller projects. This recommendation also aligns with the State Density Bonus Law where 10% low-income (or 5% very low-income) housing development projects allow a 20% density bonus, one financial concession, and development standard waivers.

 

Along with doing comparative analysis on cities that have a tiered approach for set-aside requirements and in-lieu fees, per the direction of the Planning Commission, the Consultant investigated a tiered structure for the in-lieu fee:

 

Tier 1: Small Infill Developments (6 to 9 units): Permitted to satisfy the 10% requirement by paying the per-square-foot in-lieu fee by right on a proportional basis (or voluntarily rounding up to construct 1 affordable unit on-site with State Density Bonus incentives).

 

Tier 2: Standard Developments (10 or more units): Prioritized to construct the 10% affordable units on-site stacked with State Density Bonus incentives, with the Total Development Cost-based in-lieu fee ($42.38/sq.ft.) serving to incentivize on-site unit production over fee payment.

 

The single primary in-lieu fee recommendation is $42.38 per square foot of new residential development, which is based on analysis of the Total Development Cost method (for a standard unit of affordable housing in San Clemente’s peer cities), calibrated to the 10% set-aside requirement. The current in-lieu fee calculation is difficult for applicants and staff to apply to projects, and the in-lieu fee presented by EPS in 2021 is far lower than most cities in Orange County have established. Currently, the Zoning Code states that “until a city-wide in-lieu fee program has been established, in-lieu fees may be established on a case-by-case basis,” which is too ambiguous for staff to readily determine - thus applicants cannot build the potential fees into their pro-forma analyses until after a project completes discretionary review. This uncertainty is an impediment to market rate and affordable housing development.  

 

In-lieu fees provide an alternative means of complying with inclusionary housing requirements and can be pooled to assist affordable housing projects. However, the amount collected from an individual project may not independently support construction of a new affordable unit. The Consultant recommends calibrating the fee to the program’s affordability objectives while considering project feasibility and the relative attractiveness of on-site production.

 

 

Considerations Identified by Staff:

Although the study provided by the Consultant provides guidance on establishing a tiered structure for in-lieu fees, set-aside requirements, and affordability terms, the immediate policy question is how to establish consistent and understandable requirements across City documents. Staff recommends that the Council first identify a preferred set-aside framework and direct preparation of the necessary amendments.

 

The Planning Commission recommended that the City Council initiate a zoning amendment and specific plan amendments for a set-aside requirement of 4%, consistent with the Housing Element and the Forster Ranch, Pier Bowl, and West Pico Corridor Specific Plans. This recommendation comes with the consideration that establishing a higher percentage across all housing developments of 6 units or greater can hinder the development of smaller scale projects. The Planning Commission recognized that the current in-lieu fee has not generated enough funds to supplement the development of an affordable housing project, which is why they also recommended that City Council direct staff to investigate a tiered structure for the in-lieu fees.

 

Program 6 calls for evaluation of the inclusionary housing requirements and related fee. The City has undertaken that work through the earlier EPS study and the updated Consultant analysis. The current action is intended to establish direction for preparing amendments, rather than to make final findings on the feasibility of a particular requirement or adopt a fee.

 

Council Options:

•                     Initiate a Zoning Amendment to SCMC 17.24 to change the set-aside requirement to 4%, and amend the Specific Plans that reference a 15% requirement (i.e. Marblehead Coastal Specific Plan, Rancho San Clemente Specific Plan, and Talega Specific Plan) to change the set-aside requirement to 4%.

 

•                     Initiate a Zoning Amendment to the Forster Ranch Specific Plan, Pier Bowl Specific Plan, and West Pico Corridor Specific Plan to change the set-aside requirement to 15% and reaffirm the 15% requirement in the zoning code.

 

•                     Initiate a Zoning Amendment to SCMC 17.24 to change the set-aside requirement to another percentage, such as the Consultant’s recommended 10%, and amend all Specific Plans to reflect that requirement.

 

•                     Direct staff to further investigate the implementation of a tiered structure for the payment of in-lieu fees based on total units proposed by an applicant and direct staff to bring back an updated City Fee Schedule to add the applicable in-lieu fee(s).

 

Environmental Review/Analysis:

Direction to initiate a proposed zoning code amendment and specific plan amendment(s), and to further evaluate an in-lieu fee, is not a “project” under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per CEQA Guidelines Sections 15060(c)(2) and 15378(a) because it does not itself amend any regulation or authorize development, and thus does not have the potential to result in direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect physical effects on the environment. Environmental review appropriate to any subsequent legislative or fee action will be addressed when that action is presented for consideration.

Fiscal Impact:

No direct fiscal impact is anticipated from providing policy direction and initiating preparation of amendments using available staff resources. Additional consultant work or expanded economic analysis could require funding. That specific cost cannot be determined at this time.

 

Potential Action(s):

recommendation

If the City Council concurs with the contents of this report, the City Council may take the following actions:

 

1.                     Open the public hearing, receive and consider public comment, and close the public hearing; and

 

2.                     Adopt Resolution 26-179, providing policy direction and initiating preparation of Zoning Code and applicable Specific Plan amendments to establish consistent inclusionary housing requirements, with the preferred set-aside percentage to be identified by the City Council, and directing staff to evaluate an updated inclusionary housing in-lieu fee, including potential tiered approaches, and return with the proposed fee and supporting analysis for separate City Council consideration.

 

end

Attachments:

1.                     City Council Resolution No. 26-179

2.                     Draft Planning Commission Resolution September 2, 2026

3.                     Houseal Lavigne Summary of Updated Memorandum

4.                     Houseal Lavigne Technical Memorandum- Redline Copy

5.                     Houseal Lavigne Technical Memorandum- Clean Copy

6.                     Public Comments

 

Notification:

Public notices were published per City and State requirements.